Skip to content
New Continent
← Back to all posts

Term Limits: The Founders' Idea of the Citizen Legislator

87% of Americans back term limits for Congress. The history of rotation in office, the Supreme Court ruling that blocked states, and the honest debate.

Cyan, black and ivory screenprint illustration: two women of different generations exchange a symbolic office key.
Illustration: New Continent

Ask Americans what they think of term limits for Congress and you get something rare these days: agreement. In a 2023 Pew Research Center survey, 87 percent of U.S. adults said they favor limiting the number of terms members of Congress can serve. That includes big majorities of Republicans and Democrats.

So why doesn't it happen? Because the only people who can easily pass it are the ones it would send home.

Rotation in Office

The idea of limiting time in power is older than the Constitution. The Articles of Confederation, the country's first governing document, said no one could serve as a delegate to Congress for more than three years in any six. The founders called this "rotation in office." The thinking was that representatives should come from the people, serve for a while, and then go back and live under the laws they made.

The Constitution dropped that rule. The framers argued about it and decided voters themselves could be the limit. Thomas Jefferson thought leaving it out was a mistake. In a 1787 letter to James Madison, he listed his objections to the new Constitution, and the second was "the abandonment in every instance of the necessity of rotation in office, and most particularly in the case of the President."

For a long time, the system mostly rotated anyway. Serving in Congress was a hardship, and many members went home after a term or two. That changed in the 20th century, as Congress became a career.

Cyan, black and ivory screenprint illustration: a hand holds a pencil over a blank notebook beside a coffee cup.
Illustration: New Continent

What the Constitution Says Now

The presidency got a limit. After Franklin Roosevelt won four elections, Congress proposed and the states ratified the 22nd Amendment in 1951, limiting presidents to two elected terms.

Congress did not get one. In the early 1990s, voters in many states passed limits on their own members of Congress. In 1995, in U.S. Term Limits, Inc. v. Thornton, the Supreme Court struck those down 5 to 4, ruling that states can't add qualifications for Congress beyond the ones in the Constitution. That means a congressional term limit now requires a constitutional amendment.

Many states still limit their own governors and legislators, and those limits are in effect today.

The Case For

Supporters make a few plain arguments.

  • Incumbents almost never lose. In 2024, the House re-election rate for incumbents running was about 99 percent. Elections are supposed to be the limit, but gerrymandered seats and fundraising advantages make most seats safe. We wrote about that in Gerrymandering: When Politicians Pick Their Voters.
  • Long tenure builds the club. The longer someone stays, the deeper the ties to lobbyists, donors, and party leaders who control committee seats.
  • New people bring outside lives. A legislator who knows they're going home soon has reason to remember what it's like to live there.
Cyan, black and ivory screenprint illustration: an older woman stands thoughtfully among fellow citizens.
Illustration: New Continent

The Case Against, Honestly

Term limits have serious critics, including many political scientists. NPR's 2023 explainer summed up the research: in state legislatures with term limits, studies have found that experience drains away, and power can shift to lobbyists, staff, and the executive branch, who stay while lawmakers churn.

That's a real risk. It's also why term limits work best alongside other reforms, not instead of them. Limit terms, but also slow the revolving door, which we cover in The Revolving Door, so departing members can't cash in. Fund strong, nonpartisan staff for Congress so lawmakers don't have to rely on lobbyists for expertise. Shine light on money so new members aren't captured on day one.

What It Would Take

A constitutional amendment needs two-thirds of both chambers and three-fourths of the states, or a convention called by two-thirds of the states. That's a high bar, and it should be. But members of Congress have introduced term-limit amendments many times, and some candidates pledge to support one. A pledge is a reasonable thing to ask for.

What You Can Do

Ask every candidate for Congress two questions. Will you co-sponsor a term-limits amendment? And how many terms will you serve, regardless of whether it passes? Write down the answers and hold them to it. Some of the most effective term limits in history were simply people who kept their word and went home.

Washington did. He could have stayed as president for as long as he lived. He served two terms and left, and that example held for nearly 150 years. In his Farewell Address, he wrote that he was going back to enjoy "the benign influence of good laws under a free government" as a private citizen. That's the whole idea.

Wear It

The point of term limits is that power belongs to the people, not to whoever has held a seat the longest. Our black cap is aimed at the system that keeps career politicians comfortable: Lobbying is a funny way to spell BRIBERY.

On WeWrite, our page on the Spirit of 1776 explains the idea behind our tagline, and the merch designs page shows the rest of the line.

Shop the Hat

For the citizen legislator in all of us. Lobbying is a funny way to spell BRIBERY, black snapbackMade on demand. Checkout on Printful.

Sources

Shop the hat