Skip to content
New Continent
← Back to all posts

The Revolving Door: How Congress Becomes a Job Interview

Most former lawmakers who take jobs outside politics go to work influencing Congress. How the revolving door works and how to shut it.

Cyan, black and ivory screenprint illustration: a woman steps through a glass revolving door between civic and office spaces.
Illustration: New Continent

Every couple of years, a few dozen members of Congress retire or lose. You might expect them to go home, the way citizen legislators were supposed to. Plenty of them don't. They move a few blocks away, to offices on K Street, and start getting paid to influence the people they used to sit beside.

This is the revolving door. It's legal. It's also one of the clearest reasons Washington feels like it runs for someone other than you.

The Numbers

Public Citizen, a nonpartisan watchdog, has tracked where former lawmakers end up for two decades. When it looked at the members of the 115th Congress (2017 to 2019), it found that of the former members who had taken jobs outside government and politics, 59 percent (26 of 44) were working for lobbying firms, consulting firms, trade groups or business groups trying to influence the federal government. Half were in lobbying or consulting outright.

That isn't new. An earlier Public Citizen analysis found that 43 percent of the members who left Congress between 1998 and 2004 and were eligible to lobby became registered lobbyists. Both parties did it.

Cyan, black and ivory screenprint illustration: a woman's silhouette repeats in the reflections of glass revolving doors.
Illustration: New Continent

The Rules Are Thin

Federal law does have a "cooling-off" period. Former House members can't lobby their old colleagues for one year. Former senators have to wait two. The restriction is in 18 U.S.C. § 207.

But as Public Citizen points out, the restrictions are narrow. A former member can lobby executive agencies right away. And they can be hired as a "strategic consultant" or "senior adviser" who tells the registered lobbyists who to call and what to say, without ever making the call themselves. On paper, they aren't lobbying. In practice, everybody in the room knows what they're being paid for.

Why It Matters While They're Still in Office

The obvious harm is after they leave: a former member trading on relationships built with your tax dollars. The deeper harm is before they leave.

If you know your next job, the one that pays several times your current salary, will come from the industries you oversee, how hard are you going to push against them? You don't have to take a bribe. You just have to be reasonable. Return the calls. Soften the amendment. Don't make enemies you might need later.

That is how a government gets captured without anyone breaking the law. We made the broader version of this argument in The Case Against Lobbying, Made Plainly. The revolving door is the career path that makes the whole system run.

Cyan, black and ivory screenprint illustration: a woman with a tote bag passes suited people entering an office lobby.
Illustration: New Continent

The Founders Saw This Coming

The Constitution's authors worried about officials whose loyalties could be bought on the installment plan. Article I bars members from being appointed to any federal office that was created, or whose pay was raised, while they served. The point was to stop lawmakers from building themselves comfortable landing spots.

In Federalist No. 57, Madison wrote that the House was designed so its members would have "an habitual recollection of their dependence on the people." The revolving door replaces that recollection with something else: dependence on future employers. You can read more of what the founders said about this in What the Founders Said About Corruption.

What Would Actually Help

Reformers on the left and right have floated the same handful of fixes for years:

  • A longer cooling-off period, measured in years, not months. Some proposals call for a lifetime ban on former members lobbying Congress.
  • Close the "consultant" loophole. If you're paid to shape lobbying strategy, you should register and disclose like a lobbyist.
  • Cover the executive branch. The ban should apply to agencies too, not only Capitol Hill.
  • Apply it to senior staff. Top congressional aides often move to K Street with even less friction than their bosses.

None of these require a constitutional amendment. They require a Congress willing to cut off its own exit ramp, which is why voters have to ask for it out loud.

What You Can Do

When your representative or senator announces retirement, pay attention to where they land. Search their name in the Senate's lobbying disclosure database a year or two later. Tell people what you find. Ask the candidates running to replace them a simple question: will you promise, in writing, never to lobby Congress after you leave?

That kind of pledge isn't legally binding. But a public promise is something you can hold them to, and it tells you who is running for the job and who is running for the job after the job.

Say It on Your Head

New Continent started with the idea that power in this country is supposed to flow up from the people, not sideways to the people with connections. Our orange cap puts the plain version on the front: Lobbying is a funny way to spell BRIBERY. It's bright enough that people will ask. When they do, tell them about the 59 percent.

We keep a short page for the slogan on WeWrite, Lobbying is a funny way to spell Bribery, and a brand page on how New Continent began.

Shop the Hat

Bright enough to start the conversation. Lobbying is a funny way to spell BRIBERY, orange snapbackMade on demand. Checkout on Printful.

Sources

Shop the hat